Late Prophet Temitope Balogun Joshua of Synagogue Church of All Nations (SCOAN). TB JOSHUA MINISTRIES / INSTAGRAM.
the MINISTRY OF CULTURAL AFFAIRS
A Man, a Church, and the Exploitation of Vulnerable Congregations
Late Prophet Temitope Balogun Joshua of Synagogue Church of All Nations (SCOAN). TB JOSHUA MINISTRIES / INSTAGRAM.
the MINISTRY OF CULTURAL AFFAIRS
A Man, a Church, and the Exploitation of Vulnerable Congregations
On the 8th of January 2024, BBC News Africa released Disciples: The Cult of TB Joshua, a three-part investigative series about the late evangelical pastor, Temitope Balogun ‘TB’ Joshua. Developed over two years, the series shed light on accusations of sexual assault, physical abuse, fabricated miracles, and alleged trauma TB Joshua and his church, Synagogue Church of Nations (SCOAN), inflicted on church members for three decades. The series featured the accounts of over 25 individuals, providing an extensive look at the controversies surrounding TB Joshua and problematizing his legacy.
The BBC documentary functions as a critique of SCOAN and, by extension, TB Joshua. However, TB Joshua did not exist in a vacuum. Rather his ministry stems from a type of Protestantism that has become endemic to the African continent. From pastors in Kenya forcing their populations to starve themselves to death to South African pastors feeding their congregants snakes. The rise and prominence of TB Joshua-esque pastors has led to several governments attempting to regulate churches.
In a time where scores of people across the world are turning their back on religion, maybe it is necessary to consider why the prosperity gospel church continues to find a foothold on this continent. TB Joshua’s ministry drew from a tradition of Black and African Protestantism that promises heavenly relief in a world marred with structural oppression, impoverishment and illness. As such, TB Joshua and SCOAN exist largely because of the society in which TB Joshua built his ministry. It is essential to consider his legacy because it provides valuable insight into the role of evangelical Christianity in Nigeria and how SCOAN and similar churches provide the moral direction for a society whose ills reverberates in the church. It is equally worth examining the racial and colonial histories that enabled the creation of SCOAN within the larger framework of evangelical Christianity, the vast wealth and political power that TB Joshua and pastors similar to him go on to amass in the name of God and the function that SCOAN and similar religious institutions play in our society.
MARK 16:15: AND HE SAID TO THEM, ‘GO INTO ALL THE WORLD AND PREACH THE GOSPEL TO ALL CREATION’
In episode one of the docu-series, the BBC gives a short history of the beginnings of SCOAN and the well-calculated strategy that TB Joshua used to market his ministry. We hear interviews from former ‘disciples’—the word TB Joshua used in referring to his most loyal followers—who reveal how they came to join the church and how they grew so devoted to TB Joshua that they gave up their lives to follow his ministry.
TB Joshua found prominence as an evangelical pastor who claimed to be ordained by God to prophesy, heal the sick, and take care of the downtrodden. He relied on television and VCR recordings in the early stages of the church, which he would hand out in large quantities to visiting pastors from the United Kingdom and South Africa to attract white evangelical Christians to SCOAN. In an interview, Anneka, a former disciple from the United Kingdom, retells how she felt drawn to some graphic video footage from the church that depicted Joshua healing people who had visible illnesses through prayer. With his hands on the bodies of the sick and downtrodden, it seemed that TB Joshua had summoned Jesus of Nazareth and the God of the Bible to Lagos, Nigeria. ‘I was so excited,’ Anneka said, ‘it is like I was going to get on a time machine and go back to biblical times and meet Jesus’. Another interviewee, Rae, discussed feeling relieved that the God she had been unable to find in the UK had materialized through the ministry of an African man. ‘I thought that maybe this was the answer to my problems,’ Rae said. Both Anneka and Rae reiterated that they felt ‘called’ to join TB Joshua’s ministry.
The documentary also showed how TB Joshua strategically enlisted white congregants to the church. In a snippet, for instance, a white South African congregant claimed that, ‘In the past I really hated blacks, I really hated them, when I got back over here I saw the love that we received from black people.’ However, this ‘sanctuary in the middle of the dark continent’ soon becomes exposed as a cult that used the labour of white people to bring legitimacy to the church.
And yet, the documentary shied away from explaining the contradiction that is created when white people are exploited in the name of God. TB Joshua himself made this exclamation clear, when according to the documentary he gloated to his confidant, Agomoh Paul, about the joy it brought him to enslave white people. He saw it as revenge for what colonists did to his ancestors.
In 1899, English writer, Rudyard Kipling, wrote the poem, ‘The White Man’s Burden’, a line from which reads: ‘The silent sullen peoples shall weigh your Gods and you.’ In the poem, Kipling argues that the conquering of native people of the world is the moral obligation and selfless duty of all white people. For a long time, many colonists believed, as do many Christians today, that bringing Christianity to nonbelievers would pave their way to the kingdom of heaven. That not only is it their moral obligation to share the word of God with non-believers but that God, also, rewards those who win souls for his kingdom.
In his book, A History of Africa, historian, J.D. Fage, describes the racially based logic of nineteenth-century European intellectuals and missionaries. According to Fage, ‘Mid-and late-nineteenth-century Europeans were generally convinced that their Christian, scientific and industrial society was intrinsically far superior to anything that Africa had produced.’ This sentiment is reiterated in Ethiopia Coming To God, the memoirs of Daniel Flickinger, a missionary who was appointed to spread Christianity to Ethiopia. In the book, Flickinger wrote, ‘The only reason why our theological views are not as foolish and corrupting as theirs, and that we are not believers in witchcraft, devil-worship, and a thousand other foolish things, is simply because the light of Heaven shines upon us.’
This history is well recorded, but missionary-style Christianity is not exactly what TB Joshua proffered. He was a Pentecostal pastor, belonging to a strain of Christianity that emerged in the late 19th century and is now the fastest-growing segment of Christianity. Pentecostalism has been criticized by other evangelical sects for promoting Christianity as a way for believers to gain health and wealth in their lifetime and exalting the prophetic powers of their leaders over that of Christ. In line with this, TB Joshua believed that baptism by the holy spirit would be marked by speaking in tongues and prophetic abilities.
In Nigeria, the Pentecostalist movement began in the early 20th century as a way to break free from Western missionary control. It then gained much support after the civil war (1967-1970), among young people, particularly the Christian Students Social Movement of Nigeria. The Christian Students Social Movement of Nigeria was established in 1977 with the aim of awakening charismatics to the social and political realities of Nigeria. Placing the growth of Pentecostalism in context is important because Pentecostalism found its stronghold in organizations like the Christian Students Social Movement of Nigeria during a time of widespread political and social suppression, where the church was one of the only ways in which young people could safely build community.
Additionally, the church provided one of the only safe manners of organizing against the state. Many of the early adherents of Pentecostalism held the belief that activism could be carried out through spiritual forces that govern politics and hoped to bring about reform through prayer.
ISAIAH 45:5: ‘I AM THE LORD, AND THERE IS NO OTHER; APART FROM ME THERE IS NO GOD’
It is impossible to consider the history of the prosperity gospel without considering the legacy of American spiritual leader, Father Divine, one of the most notorious cult leaders of the 21st century and, arguably, the father of the type of Pentecostalism that TB Joshua subscribed to. Unlike TB Joshua, Father Divine was a civil rights leader who used his platform to promote gender and sexual equality. Additionally, he provided his congregation with food, employment, affordable housing, water, and community during the great depression in America. Many of Father Divine’s congregants were African Americans who were looking for a gospel that would free them from their material conditions. In the same way, most of TB Joshua’s followers were Nigerians who had lived through widespread state mismanagement and were looking for a gospel to free them from earthly suffering.
The most important similarity between these men is the way they utilized the gospel to become extremely wealthy. Father Divine’s Peace Mission church was at one point, the largest property owner in Harlem, New York. He had branches opened in Los Angeles, California, and Seattle, Washington, and gatherings occurred in France, Switzerland, Canada and Australia. Historically, Christian sentiment has been in favour of men of God living modestly . However, as Father Divine gained prominence, the idea that God is a more-than-sufficient provider of all your needs would reverberate across many evangelical pastors and prophets, who relied on that mindset to justify their own acquisition of wealth. It is no surprise then that TB Joshua, through SCOAN, amassed considerable wealth and went on to be one of the richest pastors in the world—as of 2011, he had an estimated net worth of around $10 million.
The BBC docu-series depicts TB Joshua’s life of luxury and how he celebrated his earnings quite candidly. The docu-series also accuses Joshua of charging extortionate fees to those wishing to attend his prayer camps and live in SCOAN’s guest houses. It goes so far as to accuse him of flouting building safety precautions so that he would have space for more guests to stay, an issue that eventually led to the collapse of one of the buildings at SCOAN and the death of 115 people in 2014.
Both TB Joshua and Father Divine sought to spread their ministry to the downtrodden and, in return, expected some sort of financial compensation. It is difficult, in the case of TB Joshua, to justify the accumulation of so much wealth when 71 million people in Nigeria are grappling with extreme poverty. Despite the documentary portraying Joshua as a charitable figure who invested significantly in helping the needy and the helpless, it raises questions about the impact of his charitable schemes on the development of the cult of personality that surrounded him.
Wealth acquisition is a hotly contested topic within evangelical churches especially concerning exploitative tithing practices. In 2022, Creflo Dollar, an American pastor and a proponent of the prosperity gospel, issued a public apology for using his church to solicit donations for a new private jet. There is still a myriad of pastors who expect complete financial penance from their followers. For instance, Pastor Tobi the leader of UK-based Salvation Proclaimers Anointed Church has gone so far as to request that his congregants take out loans so that they can fulfil their obligations to him and God.
This is the paradox of the Gospel of Jesus as understood through the Pentecostal church. Jesus, a man who is remembered for physically attacking those who engaged in commercial activities outside a temple and leading a modest lifestyle, has seemingly developed a habit of appointing millionaires who aspire to own private jets as his earthly representatives. The paradox becomes more significant when we consider that many congregants contributing to these ministries live in poverty or belong to groups that have been formally exploited. The disparity in lifestyles between pastors of mega-churches and their financially struggling followers should prompt a re-evaluation of the tax-exempt status that churches enjoy and the lack of government regulation.
shop the republic
-
₦70,000.00 – ₦75,000.00Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
-
₦70,000.00 – ₦75,000.00Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
-
₦70,000.00 – ₦75,000.00Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
-
₦70,000.00 – ₦75,000.00Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
shop the republic
-
₦70,000.00 – ₦75,000.00Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
MATTHEW 21:14: AND THE BLIND AND THE LAME CAME TO HIM IN THE TEMPLE, AND HE HEALED THEM
At SCOAN, Pentecostalism is seen as a balm that can ease the socio-economic issues facing much of the developing world, Nigeria especially. The docu-series spends time dispelling the lore that sought to paint TB Joshua as a prophet with the ability to heal patients of cancer, AIDS, and various other ailments simply through the power of prayer and faith.
It is, of course, no great mystery how a church built around the rejection of modern medicine and the re-imagination of illness as a metaphysical reality (as opposed to one that could be cured by trained doctors) would become so lucrative in a country in which the healthcare system has all but collapsed. The docu-series depicts scores of people lined up outside SCOAN seeking healing; and when one considers this desperation for healing one must also consider that Nigeria’s healthcare indicators are some of the worst in Africa. Medical professionals are in short supply, with only about 35,000 doctors despite needing 237,000. Additionally, in 2024, only five per cent of the national budget was allocated to healthcare spending, compared to the 15 per cent pledge the Nigerian state made in April 2001 during the Abuja declaration.
I remember watching Emmanuel TV with my grandfather as a child and when the service ended, TB Joshua would call out to viewers at home, instructing them to place their hands on the television so that he could pray for them. He prayed for healing and called them to believe only in God as a way to overcome all financial and physical illnesses. This image stayed in my mind. I am also thinking about the countless Nigerians on social media who rely on crowdfunding for their healthcare expenses and the stories that are very close to home of loved ones and acquaintances who have died due to healthcare underfunding or malpractice. In this context, healing through the attendance of church or by simply putting your hands on the television is not only very attractive but also, sometimes, the last hope for vulnerable people.
But even TB Joshua did not fully believe in his magical powers. In the docu-series, when asked how the miracles were performed, TB Joshua’s confidant stated: ‘People with ordinary wounds, we brought them in to present as cancer… Those people were fed medication, we gave them drugs to ensure a speedy recovery.’ How many of the countless people who lined up outside the Synagogue Church of God looking for a miracle could have found the same recovery at the end of a round of antibiotics?
shop the republic
shop the republic
-
₦20,000.00 – ₦60,000.00Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
EZEKIEL 34:23: I WILL PLACE OVER THEM ONE SHEPHERD, MY SERVANT DAVID, AND HE WILL TEND THEM; HE WILL TEND THEM AND BE THEIR SHEPHERD.
The docu-series interviews TB Joshua’s devotees about the events that occurred after the collapse of the Synagogue Church of God in 2014. The collapse saw 115 people die on the church grounds in the Ikotun-Egbe area of Lagos State. According to the documentary, TB Joshua claimed that he was the victim of a planned attack by a strange aircraft. He never acknowledged or took accountability for the structural failings that caused the collapse. In the aftermath of the tragedy, former president Goodluck Jonathan visited the prophet. He stated on camera that his primary reason for his visit to the site was to express his condolences to TB Joshua, not to the countless victims or their families. Notwithstanding the information that came out from many reputable news outlets at the time—information now confirmed in the documentary—that the building’s foundation was not fit to support the building’s height.
At the height of his fame, TB Joshua had several presidents and dignitaries seeking his counsel and regularly posted his prophecies regarding the elections and other issues of state policy on Emmanuel TV’s blog. Perhaps it is worth considering how the influence of SCOAN was used in getting these leaders elected and may have gone further to dictate the policies that they championed when in power.
It goes without saying that SCOAN was used by various political hopefuls to campaign and appeal to their constituents. African presidents visited him for spiritual counselling and prophetic insights into their countries’ challenges. Along with former Nigerian president Jonathan, such presidents included John Atta Mills of Ghana, George Weah of Liberia, late John Magufuli of Tanzania, Salva Kiir Mayardit of South Sudan, André-Dieudonné Kolingba of the Central African Republic and Joyce Banda of Malawi.
It is significant that this counsel came at a time when conservative groups around the world were spending increasing amounts in African churches to influence laws, policies, and public opinion, especially against sexual and reproductive rights. Many churches are funded to import America’s cultural wars to Africa and further disenfranchise women and queer people on the continent.
It is no surprise then that in the years leading to TB Joshua’s death, Emmanuel TV’s videos were removed from YouTube for breaching their policies after TB Joshua purported to cure homosexuality in videos uploaded to the channel.
Various political dignitaries have praised TB Joshua’s legacy, some being more candid than others as to what exactly the extent of their relationship with the pastor was. President of Ghana Atta Mils went so far as to credit Joshua for his 2008 election win.
2 SAMUEL 13:14 HOWEVER, HE WOULD NOT LISTEN TO HER; SINCE HE WAS STRONGER THAN SHE, HE VIOLATED HER AND LAY WITH HER.
The docu-series goes to great lengths to excavate the sexual assault suffered by TB Joshua’s disciples. According to the BBC, TB Joshua violated many women who believed him to be providing them with spiritual counsel, all of whom may never get justice for his crimes. The allegations that he designed the living quarters at his church in such a manner that sexual violence could easily be perpetuated are even more distressing.
TB Joshua, however, is not the first religious leader to have been accused of sexual violence. In recent years, church leadership at Hillsong, the Commonwealth of Zion Assembly, and the Potter’s House have all been accused of sexual impropriety. Abusing women is also not unique to TB Joshua, with Anita Oyakhilome the former wife of Chris Oyakhilome, the founder of Christ Embassy Ministries, recounting after her divorce, that ‘I tolerated abuse for so long’.
So maybe it is time to ask whether pastors represent a microcosm of a larger society in which men perpetrate violence against women every day with little to no consequences. In Nigeria, where 33 per cent of women and girls aged between 15 and 49 have experienced physical and/or sexual abuse in their lifetime, are ‘Men of God’ like TB Joshua part of the problem or symptoms of it?
The accusation of sexual violence against TB Joshua is alarming not only because he allegedly raped and abused many women but also because he went to the pulpit and preached that women were to blame for their rape; that spirits of sexual desire and lust could be prayed away. So where does that leave the millions of women who become victims of the ideology of the churches that promote misogyny in such a candid manner?
shop the republic
MATTHEW 5:3 BLESSED ARE THE POOR IN SPIRIT: FOR THEIRS IS THE KINGDOM OF HEAVEN
It is impossible to look at the healing miracles on Emmanuel TV without considering the shortcomings of Nigeria’s healthcare system. Additionally, we cannot consider how TB Joshua used charity to build his cult of personality without considering the extreme poverty surrounding his church, and the questionable alliances with politicians that shielded him and continue to shield prominent religious figures from legal consequences of their actions.
The influence of churches like SCOAN will continue to rise if governments fail to provide essential services to their citizens and force them to look to God for issues that can be resolved by better governance. It is not sufficient to continue to subject people to misery on Earth in hopes that their suffering will be rewarded in the afterlife⎈