The North African Novel in English: What Is It? How Is It?

The North African Novel

(L-R) Laila Lalami, Ahdaf Soueif, and Hisham Matar. Photo illustration by Dami Mojid / THE REPUBLIC.

THE MINISTRY OF WORLD AFFAIRS

The North African Novel in English: What Is It? How Is It?

Arabophone and Francophone literatures have dominated the region of North Africa for decades, but now a third one is emerging—the Anglophone one.
The North African Novel

(L-R) Laila Lalami, Ahdaf Soueif, and Hisham Matar. Photo illustration by Dami Mojid / THE REPUBLIC.

THE MINISTRY OF WORLD AFFAIRS

The North African Novel in English: What Is It? How Is It?

Arabophone and Francophone literatures have dominated the region of North Africa for decades, but now a third one is emerging—the Anglophone one.

An important yet often ignored development has occurred in the literary sphere of the African continent—North African writers author books in English now. They exist. They are read. They are celebrated. Arabophone and Francophone literatures have dominated the region of North Africa for decades, but now another one is sproutingslowly and sporadically. But stillit is sprouting. And it attempts to squeeze a position not only among the literatures of the region but also the continent. It is a literature originally written in English, not in Arabic, not in French. So, who are its pioneers? Why are they considered important writers? What do they write about? Do they identify as African writers?  

WHAT IS IT?

It is a new literary tide. Like many emerging literatures, this one has representatives, writers who have established its foundations, either intentionally or unintentionally, either consciously or inadvertently. Who are they? Where do they come from? I classify the following writers as the pioneers of the North African novel in English: Ahdaf Soueif (Egyptian), Laila Lalami (Moroccan) and Hisham Matar (Libyan). Although few in number, the authors in question have attracted a significant number of readers, both continentally and internationally. They are prominent and award-winning. They are commercially successful and widely read. They have even scored representation in the global canon. They have been creatively active for years, producing acclaimed literary works written in English—originally written in English. They have won and been nominated for major literary prizes, such as the Pulitzer Prize, the Booker Prize, the National Book Award and many others.  

Who was the first writer to plant the seed of this literature and water it with their literary production? In the 1970s, Nadine Gordimer, the South African author, famously enthroned Nigeria’s Chinua Achebe as ‘the father of African literature.’ I endorse Soueif as ‘the mother of the North African novel in English.’ She was the first bud of this tide, its first stem. She’d bloom and become creatively active early in the 1980s. She’s not only a novelist but also a political and cultural commentator, an activist who writes both in English and Arabic. She has published five works of fiction, some of which are award-winning. Her first published work in English was a short story collection—Aisha (1983). Her first novel, In the Eye of the Sun, was published in 1992. Her third and most prominent work, The Map of Love, was published in 1999 and shortlisted for the 1999 Man Booker Prize.  

Being shortlisted earned her cultural visibility, which would subsequently aid her in her political and social activism in Egypt and the Middle East. It would, however, distract her literary production. She has not published a work of fiction since 2007. Her latest is I Think of You (2007), a collection of selected stories previously published in Aisha (1983) and Sandpiper (1996). Miss Soueif would remain in the vanguard of this unplaced literature until the late 2000s, as Lalami and Matar were emerging, as they were making a name for themselves. Both Mr Matar and Miss Lalami published their debut works in the mid-2000s: Lalami with her short story collection Hope and Other Dangerous Pursuits (2006) and Matar with his novel In the Country of Men (2006).  

What makes Achebe’s Things Fall Apart (1958) timeless? This novel is well-established in African literature and is widely taught both in African and non-African universities. This key novel was arguably the first novel that furnished the basic structure of African literature and subsequently inspired and guided other African writers to construct the rest of its foundations. Being a pioneer novel, a first, is the characteristic that has attained it its esteemed canonical status. As reasoned by the Polish historian Piotr Wilczek, canonical works are ‘foundational’ and so are Soueif’s, Matar’s and Lalami’s. Those writers are outliers, literary rebels. They are distinguished by their language choice, especially Matar and Lalami, whose countries did not have a wide influence of English as a colonial/postcolonial language. This North African literature is endorsed by authors who challenge the long tradition and convention of either writing in Arabic or/and French. It is a literature about North Africa, written by North Africans, in English. The anglophone works that had preceded them had been largely written by non-North Africans, such as Paul Bowles’ The Sheltering Sky (1949) and Michael Ondaatje’s The English Patient (1992). This is an original literary operation, and significant in tracking its inception, its roots. Significant is mapping its traits, concerns and themes.  

shop the republic

shop the republic

Regarding the themes of North African novels in English, they are ones constantly associated with African literature. Similar to Nigerian Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s literary concerns, these writers explore aspects of postcolonialism, neo-colonialism, immigration, hybridity, otherness, diaspora and exile. Lalami is herself an immigrant, living in the diaspora, in the United States. And she contemplates on these experiences in her narratives. For example, Hope and Other Dangerous Pursuits (2006) is a collection of interlinked stories dealing essentially with illegal immigration (el-Harga), diaspora, and certain ailments of the Moroccan society. In this collection, using several stereotypical Moroccan characters, she attempts to deduce the reasons why immigration to Europe is coveted and obsessively pursued. Secret Son (2009), her first novel, is a criticism of classicism in Morocco, of national identity, starring the young Youssef El Mekki, who is impoverished and estranged in the slums of Casablanca with his single mother.  

The Moor’s Account (2015) is Lalami’s take on slavery in the US. It is a historical novel that features Mustafa ibn Muhammad ibn Abdussalam al-Zamori, a Moroccan stranded and exiled in the New World, enslaved by two Spaniards in sixteenth-century Florida. In this award-winning novel, Lalami explores themes of home, alienation, nostalgia, repatriation. Lalami’s The Other Americans (2018) diagnoses contemporary subjects, namely xenophobia, racism, underrepresentation, and otherness in the US. Similarly, cultural hybridity colours Soueif’s works. The Map of Love (1999) recounts the transcontinental, and intercultural love story of Anna Winterbourne and Sharif al-Baroudi. Furthermore, the theme of displacement pervades in her short story collections, especially in Aisha (1983) and I Think of You (2007).  

What about Matar? Mr Matar has lived most of his life in exile and the diaspora, and he has instilled this in his characters. In the Country of Men (2006), Suleiman, the protagonist, is forced to leave Libya and self-exile to Cairo. The title of his second novel is self-explanatory: Anatomy of a Disappearance (2011). The work anatomizes the life and times of an exiled family living in Cairo and in other cities. The mother country of the exiled is unnamed, turning the story into a universal story of forced displacement and unwanted mobility. Like his characters, exile and immigration pain the author as well; he writes about them personally and candidly in his memoir The Return (2017), a heart-breaking commentary on his eventual return to Libya, after more than thirty years of absence, searching for his missing father, who is yet to be found. Additionally, Matar lectures on exile literature at Barnard University. 

Notably, the three authors have contributed to the cultural production of North Africa and to the cultures of their respective countries. They have brought their homelands and their people to the English language. They have further enriched African literature. They introduced global readers to the region of North Africa, to the various issues of its inhabitants, and they have garnered many prizes as a result. Prizes, as known, have the ability to define artists, score them visibility, even pedestalize them.  

As James English stresses in The Economy of Prestige (2005, p. 21), ‘it is the prize, above all else, that defines the artist.’ And these specific authors are defined and identified by many international ones. Matar’s five works have been accoladed by prize institutions more than 28 times. In the Country of Men (2006), his debut novel, won the 2006 Guardian First Book Award, the 2007 Royal Society of Literature Ondaatje Prize and the 2007 Commonwealth Writers’ Prize of Europe and South Asia. Besides, it was shortlisted for the 2006 Man Booker Prize and nominated for the 2008 National Book Critics Circle Awards. The book has also received rave reviews by world-known writers, namely Anne Michaels, Nadeem Aslam and J. M. Coetzee. The Return (2017) is arguably Matar’s most successful and recognizable work. This memoir has grounded him as a serious literary figure, and he won the 2017 Pulitzer Prize for it, the first Libyan—and North African—to do so. Colm Tóibín deemed it ‘likely to become a classic.’ This is an author whose works have been described as ‘brilliant,’ ‘moving’ and ‘exquisite.’ Soueif, reviewing Anatomy of a Disappearance (2011), was ‘spellbound’ by it. Peter Carry, the Australian novelist, deemed Matar’s fourth book—A Month in Siena (2019)—as ‘a treasure for the ages.’ Matar even received a favourable review from Michiko Kakutani, a literary critic notorious for giving harsh reviews. My Friends (2024), his latest novel, has already been reviewed positively, praised widely by well-established critics like James Wood.  

Likewise, Lalami has received rave reviews from fellow authors and literary magazines. Hope and Other Dangerous Pursuits (2006), her debut short story collection, was described by Pulitzer Prize winner Junot Díaz as ‘a dream.’ The New York Times Book Review (2006) called it ‘poetic.’ Her first novel, Secret Son, was published in 2009. Gary Shteyngart, reviewing it, said that ‘Lalami has talent to burn.’ This is a novelist whose prose was applauded by her fellow African novelists. For example, Nigeria’s Chris Abani described her work as being ‘robust and elegant.’ The Moor’s Account (2015), Lalami’s third fiction work, is her most well-received, profusely acclaimed book. It was a finalist for the 2015 Pulitzer Prize, was longlisted for the 2015 Man Booker Prize and has raked many other recognitions. Salman Rushdie called it ‘brilliantly imagined.’ Ngugi wa Thiong’o said: ‘Lalami gives voice to the silences of history.’ The New Yorker hailed it an ‘ambitious historical novel.’  

shop the republic

shop the republic

shop the republic

HOW IS IT?

How is the North African novel in English? Is it doing well for itself? Internationally, yes. Commercially, perhaps. Continentally, not quite well. Obviously, as an Algerian novelist who writes in English, the emergence of the anglophone North African novel gladdens me, its global recognition inspires me. It has, as explained previously, not only enriched the region’s literatures, but also the African continent’s. It is, however, important to remember that the rise of this novel has been slow, irregular, sporadic and unacknowledged. Yes—unacknowledged, especially in Africa. Despite the various successes of its writers internationally, this literary tide remains slightly ignored in our continent, where its future continues to be unknown, where it still keeps a low profile. True, it has scored representation in the global canon, but not yet in the African canon, where it still advocates for a place.  

The circulation and recognition of the North African novel in English has been fairly modest in the African market, due to several impactful factors. Some are authorial. Some are institutional. Others are political. In fact, this latter factor was the one that obscured Matar’s works in his own country, preventing them from being read, from being taught and from being mentioned. The author has been a vocal critic of Libyan politics for years, and his books were banned as a result. Matar reflects on this in The Return (2017), ‘My books and journalism had been banned in Libya. I vividly remember the day when I discovered that the authorities had censored my work and had even forbidden editors from printing my name’ (p. 81). He wrote about a society which may not have known of his existence. I myself have never encountered a work by this North African author in any Algerian library or bookstore, not even in translation, not even in university libraries 

Let’s move on to the authorial factor, which concerns the continental identity of the novelists. Do they view themselves as African writers? Do they consider their works part of African literature? It’s hard to tell. These questions are yet to be answered satisfactorily, for those authors tend to shy away from their continental identity, and it cripples the circulation and recognition of their works in Africa. For instance, the majority of Soueif’s cultural and political activism is directed towards the Middle East, not Africa. To my knowledge, she has not expressed interest in her African identity. As for Matar, he still abstains from any continental affiliation, although his readers still attempt to place him in an African context. His Barnard University page says he was ‘born in New York City to Libyan parents…spent his childhood in Tripoli and Cairo and has lived most of his adult life in London.’ When his debut novel earned him recognition and attention, many labels were used to describe his identity, among which were ‘British Libyan’ and ‘Anglo-Arab’. What does he think about this identity? He, in his words, ‘observes it’ and it ‘amuses’ him. But he does not mention anywhere that his African identity interests him, or that his works should be canonized into African literature. 

The only outlier here, the only exception, is Lalami. She’s the only one who’s identified as an African writer, and only after she’d been denied it. This takes me to my point about the occasional institutional exclusion of North African writers from African literature. Many institutions, both African and non-African, generally do not recognize the African identity of the authors. This brings to mind an excellent example that involves Lalami. The 2015 Man Booker Prize longlist included 13 names, among whom were Lalami and Chigozie Obioma. Although both authors are African-born, only the Nigerian Obioma was announced by the Prize committee as African, while Laila Lalami’s African-ness was clearly obscured. This exclusion was subsequently echoed in a now-edited article by The Guardian’s Mark Brown (2015), who identified Obioma as ‘the sole African writer on The Man Booker Prize longlist.’ A swift, questioning response came from Lalami, who, citing The Guardian and the article’s link, protested in a now-deleted tweet, ‘Guardian: “The sole African writer [on the @ManBookerPrize longlist] is Chigozie Obioma.” Ummm……..http://t.co/dBo3E5yWW7.’ Then, asserting, she added forthrightly, ‘I am African. It’s an identity I’m often denied but that I will always insist upon.’  

This exclusion is even echoed in international films and documentaries. I was surprised by the existence of this proclivity in a 2021 BBC documentary, titled Africa Turns the Page: The Novels that Shaped a Continent. In it, David Olusoga, the presenter, talks about the African novels that ‘helped transform the image of Africa itself.’ Olusoga explains that ‘the African novel has become a superpower in the world of the novel.’ Yes, this is true and accurate and commendable. Although the inclusive word ‘African’ is repeatedly employed, we only see pictures and scenes of particular African writers, the usual suspects—Ben Okri, Aminatta Forna, Achebe, Buchi Emecheta and Ngũgĩ wa Thiong’o. Even when the documentary attempts to include a contemporary African writer, it selects a young Nigerian writer: Oyinkan Braithwaite, writer of My Sister, The Serial Killer (2018). It does not refer to North African writers at all.  

Interesting, isn’t it?  

It is, but unsurprising. Emerging literatures at times receive attention and recognition after their emergence has reached fruition. And has North African literature in English achieved that? Has the North African novel in English fully bloomed? Again, it’s hard to tell. Although this literature began emerging in the 1980s, it is still a recently developed literary space, which is a reason for ignoring it, which is a reason it still fights for a place in the African literary sphere. A few academic studies have been invested in this literature, but including it mainly in either Middle Eastern Studies, or North African Studies journals, but rarely in African Studies journals. It is still overmatched and overshadowed by Arabophone and Francophone literatures. Because it is still germinating, it has not been fully charted and studied as a third, independent literature besides the other ones that have dominated the region for decades. 

The previously mentioned authors (Lalami, Matar, Soueif) are its only generation for the moment, and their literary production has not yet matched that of North African creatives who write in Arabic and/or French. It has also not matched that of sub-Saharan writers. They are overmatched if compared to the history of anglophone sub-Saharan literature and its frequent representatives. Sub-Saharan literature in English is wealthy, extremely wealthy, and is identified and defined by a large number of authors. True, the scarcity of the anglophone North African novel empowers this obscurity. Pascal Casanova, the French literary critic, explains this situation in his book The World Republic of Letters (2004, p. 83): 

The world of letters is a relatively unified space characterized by the opposition between the great national literary spaces, which are also the oldest-and, accordingly, the best endowed-and those literary spaces that have more recently appeared and that are poor by comparison.  

Contextualizing his view here, I have to say that this anglophone North African space that ‘recently appeared’ is evidently ‘poor, compared to sub-Saharan literature. Soueif wrote nine works, only five of which are fiction. Lalami has published four fictive works, plus a non-fiction book. As for Matar, he is credited with three novels and two non-fiction books. On the other hand, sub-Saharan literature, represented by its first and second-generation writers, boasts a list of more than three hundred works. And I am just referring to the African Writers Series here, the first generation of this literature. Counting other houses and other works and younger writers could quadruple the number. 

Still, this is not about numbers, but about impact. It’s about influence. And those North African writers have influenced many writers, attracting admirers and followers, aspiring writers who wish to follow in their footsteps, including myself. I was thrilled upon discovering their works as a university student. I related to their characters, to their cultural settings, and they heartened me to adopt English as my language of expression. Another writer worth mentioning here is Noor Naga, an Egyptian. Her experimental novel If an Egyptian Cannot Speak English won not only the 2019 Graywolf Press African Fiction Prize, but also the 2022 the Center for Fiction First Novel Prize. Another is Hamza Koudri, an Algerian, whose novel Sand Roses (2023) was shortlisted for the 2022 Island Prize for Debut African Fiction. It was later published by Holland House in the UK (2023) and will be published by Masobe in Nigeria in the summer of 2024. Other writers are certainly germinating.  

So, this is the North African novel in English, and it’s still trying to make a name for itself. Now the questions are: How can we assist it? What can we do for it? Let’s answer these questions with one of my favourite Nigerian proverbs: ‘It takes a village to raise a child.’ Indeed, it does. And it also takes a continent to nurture a literature, to feed it, to protect it, to help it mature, to help it reach its potential. Let’s do that then. Let’s water the North African novel in English with recognition, with acknowledgement, with attention. Let’s embrace it. Let’s build a bright future for it. And it will certainly make us proud⎈ 

shop the republic

BUY THE MAGAZINE AND/OR THE COVER